Compatibility of Glasses with the Same CoE

Questions such as “How compatible are Wissmach W90 and Bullseye?” are asked from time to time.  This does show some awareness that Bullseye may not be Coe 90 and that CoE does not equal compatibility.  The same question may be asked about whether Youghiogheny Y96, Wissmach W96 and Oceanside are compatible with each other.

What is CoE

It is important to know what CoE means before the question can be answered.  It is a measure of average expansion from 20°C to 300°C.  This is suitable for crystalline materials as their low temperature expansion rates can be projected onto the behaviour of the material until near molten temperatures.  However, it is not suitable for non-crystalline materials, such as plastics or glass, as their behaviour is much more unpredictable as the temperature rises.  Measurementsof CoE have been made of glass at the glass transition temperatures which show at least seven times greater expansion near the annealing temperature than at 300°C. 

An extended essay on compatibility written by Lani Mcgregor is here, 

and here

Compatibility Tests

The degree of compatibility is uncertain between different manufacturers.  Each manufacturer will take their own way toward balancing the viscosity with the CoE.  While they can say their glass has similar characteristics to another manufacturer’s glass, they cannot guarantee compatibility.

When using glass from different manufacturers together, the best advice is to test the glasses yourself for compatibility. Do this before you commit to the project.  Bullseye notes how they do their stress tests on the education section.  I have been unable to ascertain how other manufacturers test for compatibility within their range of fusing glasses.  Another simple method of testing for stress is here.

There are reports that W90 and Bullseye work together and others that say they don’t.  There are those that say the 96 CoEs work with Oceanside, and those who say they don’t. Testing for yourself is the only way to know what works.

Scale

It seems that combining different manufacturers’ glasses may work at smaller scales, but less well at larger.  Since very few people test for compatibility before, or after, when combining different manufacturer's glasses, they don't know whether their pieces are showing signs of stress. Just because the pieces do not break immediately does not mean they are compatible or stress free. 

Size, Shape and Quantity

You should also note that the relative sizes and shapes of the combined glasses effect the survivability (rather than compatibility) of the piece.

Shape

The shape of the main piece has an effect.  Circular or broad ovals can contain the stress much more easily than a long rectangle or a wedge-shaped piece.

The same applies to the pieces added.  Pointed pieces concentrate the stress more than rectangular ones.  The stress from circular additions are easier than rectangles for the base piece to hold.

Placing

Where you place the additions is important.  Anything placed near the edge of the base is more likely to cause enough stress that it can not be contained and so the piece breaks.

Mass

How much of another manufacturers’ glass are you putting on the base?  The bigger the area or the thicker the piece(s) the less well the base will be able to hold the stress before breaking.