So, hypothetically, if I full fused CoE 96 glass at a typical CoE 90 schedule will it work? Or break?
For the purposes of answering this question, I am assuming CoE 96 to be Oceanside and CoE 90 to be Bullseye. They have slightly different full fuse temperature recommendations: 790°C/1450°F for Oceanside and 816°C/ 1500°F for Bullseye. This indicates that at 790°C/1450°F the Bullseye will have a contour fuse, but at 816°C/1500°F Oceanside will be over fired. So some accommodation for that may need to be made. One possibility is to compromise at 800°C/1472°F with a longer than 10 minute soak if the same profile is wanted.
Annealing
Annealing of both at the same time is possible. Paul Tarlow in his books recommends annealing both at 510°C/950°F, although Bullseye recommends 482°C/900°F as their annealing temperature. This is possible because annealing can be done over a range of temperatures. A step into some technical stuff is needed here.
Annealing is possible during a specific range of viscosities from the glass transition point (Tg) to the strain point. The annealing point (Tg) should not be confused bith the annealing temperature, because they can be different as described here. Oceanside has chosen the Tg as the annealing temperature. Bullseye average Tg is at 516°C/960°F, but they have chosen an annealing temperature close to the strain point to reduce the anneal cooling time of thick slabs. This is still within the annealing range for their glass. It is still possible to anneal Bullseye adequately at 516°C/960°F; it just takes longer to cool.
Similarly, Oceanside can be annealed at 482°C/900°F – it will still be within the annealing range. In fact, Wissmach used to recommend their W96 should be annealed at 482°C/900°F; now they recommend 516°C/960°F. Both temperatures produce good anneals when the appropriate soak times and cool rates are applied. And the attached graph shows soda lime glass (which fusing and float glass are) can be annealed within the range of approximately 540°C - 455°C (1000°F - 850°F), although annealing at the higher temperature requires more cooling time because of the increased temperature range.
In short, it is possible to anneal Bullseye, Oceanside and Wissmach at 516°C/960°F, 482°C/900°F, or anywhere between those temperatures and still have a good anneal, if adequately slow cooling rates are used.
Cooling
Cooling rates are intimately related to the anneal soak time and must be used to obtain a good anneal. Using a standard rate of cooling, such as 55°C/100°F regardless of profile or thickness will produce some unexpected breaks. The first cool to 427°C/800°F must be slow enough to maintain the 5°C difference (∆T=5) in temperature throughout the piece to below the strain point. The second cool rate is faster and allows a 10°C variation in temperature, and the final cool allows a 20°C variation in temperature. These slow rates maintain an acceptable temperature differential so the glass does not break due to contraction differences.
For example:
an anneal time of 1 hour requires cooling rates of:
- 83°C/150°F to 427°C/800°F, 0’
- 150°C/270°F to 371°C/700°F,0’
- 500°C/900 to room temperature
an anneal time of 2 hours requires cooling rates of:
- 55°C/73°F to 427°C/800°F, 0’
- 99°C/180°F to 371°C/700°F,0’
- 330/°C600°F to room temperature
an anneal time of 3 hours requires cooling rates of:
- 25°C/45°F to 427°C/800°F, 0’
- 45°C/81°F to 371°C/700°F,0’
- 150°C/270°F to room temperature
Etc.
These relationships remain constant, even though an extended anneal soak in relation to the effective thickness has been used. It may be that the decision is to anneal a 6mm/0.25” piece for two hours rather than the standard one hour. This then requires a first cool rate of 55°C/73°F instead of the faster rate of 83°C/150°F that is usual for that thickness. The following cool rates need to follow on at 99°C/180°F and 330/°C600°F for this extended anneal and cool.
Cooling rates and temperatures are consistently related to the anneal soak regardless of the manufacturer. These can be found at the Bullseye Annealing Thick Slabs for Celsius and Fahrenheit
Using the cool rates associated with the anneal soak time will provide more secure annealing. More information is available in the ebook Annealing Concepts, Principle and Practice. Also at Warm Glass and Etsy







