Relieving Existing Stress - How?

Why is the stress not relieved after the strain point when slumping?

The answer relates to whether it is on the cool or on the heat up.

Cooling

The annealing occurs at a higher temperature than the strain point. The aim of the annealing soak is to even out the temperature within the glass to be equal to or less than 5°C/10°F (∆T=5C). When this small differential in temperature is achieved, there is little stress in the glass. In an adequate anneal, stress will be relieved during the soak. This differential needs to be maintained through the first cool, taking the glass temperature to below the strain point.

Relieving stress occurs between the glass transition point to just above the strain point. The viscosity of the glass is so high below the strainpoint (brittle phase) of the glass that no stress can be relieved.

The more rapid cooling during the brittle phase of the glass needs to be slow enough to avoid creating large contraction differentials within the glass. The reason for progressive cooling stages during the brittle phase of the glass is that it can withstand greater temperature differentials and so the cooling rates can be increased.

Heat up

Any stress on the way up for an already fused piece is induced by uneven heating. This can be across the piece, which is most evident in side fired kilns. The source of the infrared heating is nearest the edge of the glass, so it heats first leaving the centre cooler – sometimes the difference in expansion is great enough to break the glass.

In top fired kilns the differential is usually between top and bottom surfaces. Glass transmits heat slowly so the difference in temperature between the top and the bottom can be enough to cause a break from unequal expansions.

Both these conditions are caused by rapid ramp rates and short anneals on the cool.

Ramp Rates

Breaking of a flat piece on the kiln shelf is from too short a soak or too fast a cool, or both (unless there is an incompatibility). Breaking in a slump most often is a result of too rapid an initial ramp rate. A fused piece needs slower ramp up rates in a slump than in the initial fuse. It is now a single thicker piece, rather than multiple pieces as at the beginning of a fuse. While you might fire a flat 6mm/0.25” piece at 200°C/360°F for the fuse, the ramp rate for the slump needs to be no more than about 100°C/180°F. Tack fused pieces need much slower heat up rates during the slump, usually only half of the rate used to fuse the piece.

Tests have shown that even though the anneal soak for both firings can be the same, a more stress-free piece can be achieved by annealing as for one layer thicker. I do not know why, but I speculate that it is more difficult to achieve the ∆T=5C in the curved piece, than in a flat one.

More information is available in the ebook Annealing Concepts Principles and Practice.

Shotgun Annealing

 Shotgun annealing is chosen when the annealing temperature is unknown or uncertain. The name comes from the characteristic spread of the shot pellets to include the target.

To follow this process, pick highest relevant anneal temperature. We know soda lime glass has a range from about 540°C/1004°F to 470°C/878°F. Unless you are firing float glass (which anneals between 540°C/1004°F and 520°C/968°F), you can start the anneal cycle at 520°C/968°F and continue it to 470°C/878°F (a 50°C range). The rate to be used is determined by the amount of time required to anneal the piece according to thickness.

To be safe, a shotgun anneal will need double the time to go through the chosen range that a normal anneal soak requires.

• A 6mm/0.25” full fused piece would normally need an hour soak. So the shotgun anneal rate would be 25C/45F per hour over a 50°C/90°F range.
• A 12mm/0.5” full fused piece would normally need a two hour soak. This implies a rate of one quarter of the range or a cool rate of 12°C/22°F over the range.
• A 6mm/0.25” tack fused piece would need to be fired for twice its thickness, so as for 12mm/0.5”.

Annealing times for different profiles and thicknesses are given in this blog post:  and in this ebook.

If the glass is really unknown or older than fusing glass, a wider shotgun anneal range should be used. This gives a temperature range of 540°C/1004°F and goes to 470°C/878°F, or a range of 70°C/126°F. There is still a requirement for the shotgun process to be double the normal anneal soak.

• So for a 6mm/0.25” full fused piece two hours are required to go through the range, or 35°C/63°F per hour.
• A 12mm/0.5” full fused piece and a 6mm/0.25” tack fused piece will need a rate that takes 4 hours to go through the range, or 18°C/32°F per hour.

Once the slow fall of temperature through the range is complete, there should be a one hour soak to ensure the temperature has been equalised throughout the reduction in temperatures. This is applicable to pieces 12mm/0.5” thick. Thicker pieces need a longer soak at this point.

The final part of the anneal is cooling at a rate appropriate for the thickness and profile. E.g.:

• A 6mm/0.25” full fused piece would be cooled at 83°C/150°F to 427°C/800°F, and then at 150°C/270°F to 370°C/700°F or lower.
• A 12mm/0.5” full fused piece needs a two hour soak, so the cooling rates are determined by that, i.e., 55°C/99°F per hour to 427°C/800°F and then at 99°C/178°F per hour to 370°C/700°F or lower.

There is an alternative process which is used to determine the annealing temperature of an unknown glass. Once the anneal temperature is determined for a glass, there is no need for a shotgun anneal process. This is known as the slump point test. 

Much more on the principles and practices of annealing can be found in my e-book. Annealing Concepts, Principles and Practice from Bullseye, Etsy and stephen.richard43@gmail.com

Annealing temperatures by colour

 It has been suggested that there are different annealing temperatures for different colour groups. This is not so.

All the colours in a single fusing compatible range are annealed at the same temperature. It is true that there are variations in the viscosities of different colours, but these are designed by the makers to be minor. Also relevant is that annealing can occur over a range, making concern about different viscosities within a fusing compatible line of glass less important. The anneal soak gives time for all the glass to reach the same temperature differential of ∆T = 5°C, where the viscosity differences will be so small as to be insignificant.

There are precautions that should be observed when combining strongly contrasting colours or contrasting styles. In general, hot and dark colours are less viscous than light and cool colours at slumping and above temperatures. There are also contrasting viscosities between opalescent and transparent colours. A cautious approach to these differences in viscosities is to anneal them as for one layer thicker than that for the profile of the finished item.

The annealing temperature remains the same for all the glass in a fusing compatible line, regardless of colour or style. The length of the anneal soak and cool rates may be altered for these contrasts, but not the anneal temperature.