Scheduling for Thick Landscapes

Thick slabs often involve numerous firings of increasingly thick work.  I am using an existing example, with their permission, of the first stages of a thick landscape.  The initial concern was with bubbles in the first layup, then the strategy for firing the thick slab.

Plans

This is the first part of a landscape with depth.  It will be fired 5-7 more times.  This first piece will be inverted for the next firing with the clear facing up, to avoid reactions between the colours.  It is similar to an open face casting. There is a Bullseye Tip Sheet on open face casting that will give a lot of information.

Layup

Picture credit: Osnat Menshes

This work has a base of clear that is mostly overlaid with one layer of 3mm pieces, although in some places another layer, and there are some pre-fired elements as well.  It is fired on Thinfire shelf paper.

Bubbles 

There is concern about the number and size of the bubbles after the firing, and how to avoid them.  Will they grow over the multiple firings?

The many small bubbles are characteristic of kilnformed glass.  The few larger bubbles may result from the frit that is under the pieces that form the top surface.  And there are some overlaps of clear over colour that may form pockets where air can collect. I advise leaving the scattering of the frit until all the decorative pieces are in place.  The bubbles will migrate toward the top during the multiple firings.  They will not grow in size unless they combine during the upward migration.  A later suggestion about reducing the number of firings will reduce the bubble migration and risk of increasing in size.

Picture credit: Osnat Menshes

Schedule

Proposed Schedule (Temperatures in degrees Celsius)

1: 180 – 560, 30’    I would go to 610 for 30'

2: 25 – 680, 120’    I would use only 30'

3: 220 – 810, 15’    I would set the top temperature at 816, 15’.

4: 9999 – 593, 30’  Eliminate this segment. 

5: 9999 – 482, 120’ I suggest one hour soak

8: 55 – 370, off      83 – 427, 0’

7: 150 – 371, 0’

8: 330 – to room temperature, off.

 

Eliminate segment number 4.  Any temperature equalisation done at this temperature, is undone by the AFAP to the  annealing.  The temperature equalisation occurs at the annealing temperature. No soak at an intermediate temperature is required.  This blog post gives some information about annealing above and below the annealing point (Tg). 

Firing Incremental Layers

The plan is for five to seven more firings.  Continuing to build up the thickness on each firing, may have some problems.

• There is increased risk of compatibility problems when firing a piece to full fuse many times.
• There is a risk of more bubbles and of the existing ones becoming larger as they move upwards and combine with other smaller ones.
• With each firing the thickness is increasing and so becoming a longer firing.  This is because the heat up, annealing, and cooling each need to be longer.  For example - 6mm needs 3hour cooling, 12mm needs 5 hours, 19mm needs 9 hours. 

Multiple Slabs

These are the main reasons that I recommend firing a series of 6mm slabs separately and combining them in one final firing.  Firing a series of 6mm slabs and then combining them in a single long and slow final firing has advantages.

• The individual pieces do not need to go through so many full fuse firings, reducing the risk of compatibility problems.
• The small bubbles in each firing will not have the chance to rise through all the layers to become larger.
• The total time in the kiln for the combined pieces will be less than adding layers to already fired layers.

Examples

It is often difficult to convince people that firing by adding incrementally to an existing slab, longer firing times are required than by firing a group of 6mm slabs and a single combined firing of all the slabs.  I give an example to illustrate the differences.

Annealing

Assume there are to be a total of eight firings (existing 6mm slab and 3mm for each of seven more firings).  Also assume that each additional firing is of 3mm. This makes a total of 28mm.  Compare annealing and cooling times for each firing:

Firing      thickness       anneal and cool (hours minimum)

1            6mm                    3

2            9mm                    4

3            12mm                   5

4            15mm                   7

5            18mm                   9

6            21mm                   11.5

7            25mm                   14

8            28mm                   17

Total                                   70.5 hours annealing time (minimum)

To fire up 5 six millimetre slabs takes less time – 3 hours annealing and cooling time for each firing cumulates to 15 hours.  Add to that the final firing of 17 hours annealing time.  A total of 32 hours.  This is half the time of adding to the existing slab at each firing.  Multiple 6mm slabs can be fired at the one time if there is space in the kiln, which would reduce the kiln time for the 6mm slabs even further. 

An additional advantage of firing 6mm slabs and combining them, is that bubbles can be squeezed out more easily in the final thick slab fring because of the combined weight of the  slabs.  You could make the individual slabs a little thicker, but that would involve damming each slab.  Not an impossible task of course.  And it would change the calculations, by reducing the number of firings.

Heat Up

Another time saving is to use the second cooling rate from the Bullseye document Annealing Thick Slabs as the first up ramp rate. Take this rate up to a minimum of 540˚C. Although, this is an arbitrary temperature above the strain point to ensure all the glass is above the brittle phase.  It is possible to maintain this initial rate to the bubble squeeze.  But with the slow rises in temperature required for thicker slabs, it is sensible to increase the rate from 540 to bubble squeeze to reduce the firing time.  Once past the bubble squeeze a more rapid rate can be used to the top temperature.  

The heat up times could be about half the minimum cooling times.

A worked example (with certain assumptions) would be:

Firing      thickness       time to top temperature total time.

1            6mm             6.3               

2            9mm             7.1

3            12mm            8.4

4            15mm            10.7

5            18mm            15.9

6            21mm            19.4

7            25mm            25.1

8            28mm            29.1              ca.122 hours

But firing five times for 6mm equals 31.5 hours plus the final firing up of 29.1 hours equals a total of 60.6 hours.  Again about one half the time of progressively building up a base slab to the final thickness.

Savings

This example shows that approximately 90 hours of firing time can be saved by making a series of six millimetre slabs and combining them in a final firing.  There is the additional advantage of reducing the occurrence of bubbles between the layers in the final firing because of the weight of the combined slabs.

Kilnforming with 3mm Glass

 A power point presentation I made a few months ago to the group Lunch with a Glass Artist.

It is 33 slides long.

Kilnforming with 3mm Glass.pptx

Causes of Large bubbles

 Let’s think about moisture and large bubbles from under the glass. It is not the water, but the gasses created by the decomposition of materials that can cause the bubbles. There are other causes of large bubbles too. The most common causes are discussed here.

The usual explanations are:

• ·        Uneven shelf
• ·        Heat resistant particles under the glass
• ·        Uneven heating
• ·        Glues
• ·        Organic material
• ·        Moisture
• ·        Amount of gas

 

image credit: Warm Glass

Uneven shelf

Shallow depressions in shelves can cause large bubbles. Occasionally, the shelf can be damaged in various ways causing scratches or dings in the shelf. Air can be trapped in these depressions. And it does not take much volume of trapped to be a problem. The heat of kilnforming causes the air to expand. As the glass becomes less viscous with increased temperature, the pressure from the expanding air forces the glass upwards. The amount of air and the amount of heat work combine to create bubbles from simple uprisings to large thin walled or even burst bubbles.

There are some things that can be done to detect and avoid bubbles from forming. It is possible to screed powdered kiln wash over kiln washed shelf. This gives pathways for the air to escape. It does leave a more marked bottom surface than kiln wash.

Using 1mm or 2mm fibre paper allows air from under glass. You can maintain a relatively smooth surface with Papyros or Thinfire over the fibre. Even Thinfire or Papyros on its own will allow air from under the glass.

Checking for depressions can be done by spreading kiln wash powder over shelf and drawing a straight edge over the shelf. Depressions will be shown by the presence of the powder. It can also be done with powdered glass frit.

Particles under glass

Any particle resistant to kilnforming temperatures holds the glass up while it is forming so creating an air space. It is important to ensure the shelf is clean as well as flat. Small pieces of grit or dirt that are resistant to high temperatures will hold the glass up from the shelf enough to create a bubble – small or large depending on the temperature. Vacuuming the shelf before adding anything to the surface before each firing is important to bubble free results.

Uneven heating

This is sometimes cited as a cause of bubbles. If so, the heat would need to be very localised. This is possible if the glass is very near elements. In general, the temperature is equalised at a distance equal to the width of the elements.

Glues

A wide variety of glues are used in kilnforming. Those available to enthusiasts all burn away leaving gasses between layers. These gasses - if trapped - can thin the glass below as well as above the glue’s position. This will give the impression that the bubble has come from between the shelf and the glass. Most often the bubble forms between the glass layers, pushing a bubble only into or through the top layer. The solution is to avoid using glue or minimise it and place it only at the edges.

Organic material

Organic materials can be a problem. When you are using a large or thick fibre paper sheet under a piece of glass, occasionally the gasses from burning out of the binder can be great enough to create a bubble. Although normally, this only leaves a grey to black mark on the underside of the glass. Vermiculite boards need to be fired before use, as they contain significant amounts of binder.

Inclusion of organic materials such as leaves, twigs, or bones, leads to bubbles. Very long soaks below the softening point of the glass are required to allow the organic material to burn out of the objects.  The time required increases from an hour for leaves to 24 for bones.

Moisture

Moisture is very often cited as the source of bubbles. It is possible that the steam from water may be trapped in shelf depressions, or the areas held up from the shelf. And anytime there are no precautions to allow the air from under the glass, or between sheets bubble formation can be promoted. If adequate precautions are taken (flat shelf, clean shelf, bubble squeeze) the moisture will evaporate before the glass is hot enough to form a seal around the edges and trap any steam. It is another good reason for moderate ramp rates at the beginning of a firing.

Amount of gasses

Of course, if there is a lot of moisture there can be problems. Simply applying kiln wash in four coats does not leave enough water in the shelf to be a problem.

If you have washed the kiln wash off a mullite shelf, there will be a lot of water in it even after it feels dry. Then it does need to be kiln dried before use. To avoid breaking the shelf you need to fire slowly to 99°C/210°F and soak there for a couple of hours with the vents open or lid propped up a little to allow the moisture out of the kiln.

 

 

Texture Moulds

 Texture moulds are a form of bas relief in reverse. The texture of the mould is the bas relief. The glass formed over the shapes is in negative relief. The light is refracted through th
e back to give an image of bas relief although the surface is smooth.

 

Example of wave form texture mould

 These moulds are prone to produce bubbles at the generally recommended tack fuse temperatures. The glass often sticks to the mould if there is not sufficient draft to the parts of the image, or if insufficient separator is used. Often the moulds are produced with a rim around the edges, which trap the glass.

 The usual temperatures are too high. These moulds are an exercise in patience. The temptation is to fire higher than slumping temperatures to get good definition in the glass. However, a number of problems, especially bubbles, can be avoided by staying at the high end of slumping temperatures. This means the top temperature would be about 680C. To compensate for this low temperature, the soak needs to be three hours or more. To be sure the definition desired has been achieved, peeking near the end of this long soak is necessary. 

 Moulds that are produced with a rim around the edges can trap air and create bubbles. The rim forms a perimeter dam to confine the glass. If the rate of rise is quick to a high temperature, the edges can be sealed against the rim before all the air has escaped. It is advisable to cut the glass for these rimmed moulds a bit smaller than the internal dimensions formed by the rim.

 

Example of textured area surrounded by a rim

 Use of single layers on texture moulds can lead to large, thin bubbles. This is most prevalent when using high temperatures. Since the single layers tend to form more slowly than an already fused two-layer piece, the temptation is to use higher temperatures. The higher temperatures soften the glass to such an extent that often bubbles form over the lower areas of the mould. Instead, low temperatures with extremely long soaks should be used to allow the glass to conform to the undulations of the texture without dog boning or developing bubbles. Of course, peeking will be required to determine when the texture is achieved. With single layers, the surface will have greater undulations than with two layers. The thinness of the single layer cannot fill the depression the way two layers can.

 

 Rapid rates to high temperatures can produce internal bubbles too. These moulds have a multiplicity of hollows and depressions. Just as people are warned about depressions in their shelves, the depressions in the texture moulds can cause bubbles too. This means there are even more possibilities for bubble creation than on apparently flat shelves. Long slow bubble squeezes are required to allow air from under the glass.

 Glass sometimes sticks to the mould. This is most often blamed on insufficient separator. Boron nitride is a good separator for these moulds especially if you go to tack fusing temperatures. At slumping temperatures, kiln wash will normally be sufficient. Both of these separators need to be applied carefully, as there are relatively steep slopes throughout the mould. Spraying needs to be done from at least four angles to ensure all the sides are covered.

 Painting on kiln wash is a little more difficult, as the solution is so liquid, it tends to run down the slopes without much sticking. One means of rectifying this is to tip the mould in a circular motion to move the still liquid kiln wash solution around the slopes.

 Less often thought about is the draft of the shapes of the mould. If the slopes (draft) in the mould are too steep, the glass will “grab” the ceramic mould, because the ceramic contracts less than the glass when cooling. If shapes of the mould are steep and deep enough, the glass may even break as a result of this compression of the mould.

 

An example of some nearly vertical elements and a rim

 Of course, if a flat front surface is required, a higher than slumping temperature must be used. This is required to allow the glass to flow to the lower portions of the mould. It still should be as low as possible, but with very long soaks.

 Avoidance of bubbles on, and sticking to, texture moulds is best achieved by avoiding high temperatures, use long soaks, use two layers, and avoid extending glass to the rim. These combined with observation of the progress of the firing will produce the best results.

 

Other information is available:

Low Temperature Kilnforming, an Evidence-Based Approach to Scheduling, an ebook

Bas relief

Layups promoting bubbles

 

Problems when Slumping

A range of problems appear in slumping.  These include bubbles, splits, puddling and more. Several causes are possible.  This blog looks at the problems, possible causes and remedies.

Bubbles

Blocked Vent Holes

 Absence of, or blocked holes at the bottom of the mould to allow air out into the kiln on all but shallow or cylindrical moulds can be a cause of bubbles. Prop the mould up on stilts if the hole does not go directly from under the glass and out of the side of the mould. Alternatively, drill a hole in the side to allow the air to escape from under the mould.

Wet moulds

In kiln forming, the moisture resulting from recently applied kiln wash is considered by some to be a cause of bubbles. The water in the mould will be evaporated by around 250°C/482°F in any sensible slumping schedule. At this temperature, the glass will not have begun to move, so the moisture can move out of the mould through any vent holes at the bottom of the mould, or past the glass as it rests on the edge of the mould.

The circumstance when a damp slumping mould could cause difficulties is when using an extremely fast rise of temperature. This is detrimental to the mould also, as the rapid formation of steam is more likely to break the mould rather than the glass. It is also unlikely to result in a good slump conforming to the mould without significant marking.

In casting with wet plaster/silica moulds water vapour can move toward the glass. Casting practice has alleviated some of the problem, by having an extended steam out before 200°C/395°F, or pouring the glass into the hot dry mould from a reservoir.

In pate de verre, the mould is most often packed while wet. The small particles normally allow any steaming of moisture to pass through, and so be dry at forming temperatures without blowing any bubbles.

Top Temperature

Bubbles at the bottom of the glass are much more likely to be the result of too high a process temperature if the previous two conditions are met. This high temperature allows the glass to slide down the mould.  The glass is not plastic enough to thicken and form a puddle at the bottom at most slumping temperatures. Instead, it begins to be pushed up from the lowest point due to the weight of the glass sliding down the sides.

 

Avoiding uprisings on the bottom of bowls.

Vent Holes

Make sure the holes are clear before placing the glass.

Wet Moulds

Ensure that the moulds are no more than damp before placing in the kiln.

Top Temperature

Firing for too long or at too high a temperature will cause the glass to continue sliding down. Having nowhere else to go, the bottom begins rising. This is the result of the weight of glass pressing down onto the bottom, especially on steep-sided moulds. This is a consistent experience across several kilns and with multiple users.

Low Slumping Temperatures.

Glass at low temperatures is affected largely by its weight and viscosity.

Viscosity Effects

Thick glass will fall more slowly than thin, when using the same schedule. Thick glass takes longer to equalise the upper and lower surface temperatures. Since the lower surface is stiffer (has a higher viscosity) it will move less using the same heat up rate. This means slower rates should be used, or a significant soak just above the strain point will be required. This softening of the glass evenly throughout the rise to the top temperature is critical in obtaining even slumps.

Splits in slumps

Without the slow progress to top temperature there can be problems. Sometimes the upper surface of the slump appears fine. It is the bottom that exhibits a split or tear that does not go all the way to the upper surface of the glass. It indicates the rate of advance was too - but only just - too fast to achieve the desired result.

 The ramp rate has been quick enough to get the top heated and become plastic. But the lower surface is still cold enough that it is brittle. The weight of the upper softened glass begins to push down before the bottom has become hot enough to be fully plastic. The force of the weight on the bottom can be enough to cause the glass to separate, rather than move as the surface does. This split on the bottom but not the top indicates a slower rate for that thickness is required. This shows the interaction between viscosity and weight.

 Sometimes the split is evident from the top. The cause of this kind of split is the same as a split on the bottom. But the ramp rate has been much faster in relation to the thickness or profile of the piece.

Weight

It is possible to have glass slightly overhang slumping moulds if you use low temperatures. The glass has the appearance of behaving differently at these low temperatures than at fusing temperatures.  

 

At low temperatures it cannot form exactly to the mould. It falls first in the middle. Because the glass is not very plastic, the edges rise up from the mould at first, because the weight there is not great enough to allow the unsupported glass to bend. The edges stay in line with the beginning of the bend in the middle.  

 

At the beginning of the slump the glass is not soft enough to stretch. It maintains its dimensions as it falls. For deep moulds, the glass moves progressively to move over the lip of the mould and begins to fall into the mould.

As the slump proceeds, the glass stretches very little and so the edges move further down the mould. The glass continues to slide down at the edges until the centre settles down onto the mould bottom. 

During this slide into place, the glass can become marked. This is usually most evident on back of the upper portions of the glass where most sliding is happening.

 With higher than necessary temperatures, the glass can continue to slide down the mould. Since the glass is still not fully plastic, the weight pushes the glass at the bottom upwards. This gives the appearance of a bubble, but is an uprising due to the pressure of the glass at the sides of the mould.

 

During the sliding of the glass along the mould, it becomes more marked. The marks often look like stretch marks. And in many senses, it is exactly that.

At higher temperatures or longer holds, the glass softens more. At this point the uprising collapses and the glass begins to thicken at the bottom. It also thins slightly at the top.

Remedies

Ramp Rates

The ramp rates should be slow.

• ·        This allows the glass to heat evenly throughout. This is important to get even slumps. 
•          Contrasting colours or a combination of opalescent and transparent glasses heat evenly with slow rates.
• ·        Slow rates allow glass with tack profiles to heat evenly.
• ·        It helps avoid splits in the bottom of slumped glass.
• ·        It allows lower slump temperature to be used.

Low Temperatures

Using the lowest practical slumping temperature gives the best results.

• ·        It allows glass with small overhangs of the mould to be successfully slumped.
• ·        Low temperature reduces the mould marks on the back of the glass.
• ·        Fewer stretch marks are in evidence.
• ·        Low slumping temperatures with long soaks reduce the uneven slump that is sometimes in evidence with deeper moulds.
• ·        Low temperatures allow different colours to heat more evenly.
• ·        Low temperatures reduce the thinning or thickening of glass in a high temperature slump.

More information is available here.

This information shows you need to keep the slumping temperature to the minimum required. To find out what that temperature is, watch the slumping in stages in brief peeks (do not stare!). Look at the piece for a second or two every five minutes before you reach your desired temperature and at intervals throughout the hold.

If it has slumped completely at the beginning of the hold, you are firing too high. Reduce your temperature in subsequent firings and watch in the same way to find what the required temperature and time is. There is absolutely no substitute in slumping but to watch by peeking to learn what your mould and glass require. 

What Temperature?

To determine the temperature needed for your piece, use slow ramp rates – between 100°C to 150°C/ 180°F to 270°F. Set your top temperature around 630°C/1170°F for a simple slump of fusing glass. For bottle or window glass you will need a temperature closer to 720°C/1330°F.

It is necessary to observe the progress of the slump as you do not know the best slumping temperature. Start watching the glass at about 10-minute intervals from about 600°C/1110°F. There is not much light in the kiln at this temperature, so an external light is useful. You can also observe the reflections of the elements on the glass. When the image of the elements begins to curve, you know the glass is beginning to bend. You then know that is the lowest possible slumping temperature when using that ramp rate.

Hold for at least 30 mins at the temperature when the glass begins to visibly drop. This may or may not be long enough. Continue checking at 5-10 minute intervals to know when the slump is complete. If the glass is completely slumped before the soak time is finished, advance to the next segment. If not fully slumped, you need to extend the soak time. These operations mean you need to know how to alter your schedule while firing. Consult your controller manual to learn how to do these things. Stop the hold when complete and advance to the anneal.

In some cases, you may need to increase temperature you set by 5-10°C. You can do this by scheduling a couple of segments with 10°C/18°F higher temperature each and 30 minute soaks each.  If you do not need them, you can skip them. If you do need the extra temperature, you have it scheduled already.  You will know if you need the extra segments by whether the glass has begun to curve at the start of the first of the soaks.  If it has not after 10 minutes, skip to the next segment. Once the new temperature has been reached, check for a curve in the glass. Again, if after 10 minutes there is no curve, skip to the next (higher temperature) segment.

A low temperature slump will allow the glass to conform to the shape of the mould without softening so much that it takes up all the markings of the mould. That in turn means there are spaces for the air to escape from under the glass all the way to the slumping temperature as well as through the air holes at the bottom. It also gives the most mark-free slump possible for your shape.

If you are slumping at such a temperature that the glass has sealed to the mould, you are firing too hot anyway. Or put more positively, use a low temperature slump, that is, a slump at the lowest temperature to achieve the desired result over an extended period of your choice.

More information is available in the eBook Low Temperature Kilnforming available through Etsy or Bullseye.

Simultaneous Fusing and Slumping

“I sometimes slump at the same time as I do a tack fuse. Is slumping at this higher heat bad for the mould? “

Image credit: Creative Glass

Mould

 It is possibly not bad for the mould, but it does depend on your temperature and heat work.  Ceramic moulds are typically fired to 1200° or 1300°C so higher kilnforming temperatures are unlikely to affect the moulds.  The speed at which the target temperature is reached is of concern though.  Ceramics have what is called quartz inversions.

 Two of the constituents of ceramics – cristobalite and quartz – have significantly large expansions at 226°C and 570°C / 440°F and 1060°F.  Rapid rises through these two temperatures risks breaking the ceramic mould.  This is not the case with steel moulds, of course.

Glass

 There may also be effects on the glass.  Slumping typically ranges between 620°C to 677°C (1150°F to 1250°F).  Tack fusing typically is done in the 740°C to 790°C (1365°F to 1455°F)range.  This is a significant difference even at the higher end of the slumping range and the lower end of the tack fusing range. 

 Some of the effects are:

·        The marking of the slumped glass will be greater at tack fusing. 
·        The glass will slip down the mould more. 
·        Any pieces applied to the base are likely to slide during the slumping process.
·        There is a risk of creating an uprising or bubble at the bottom as the glass slips down the side of the mould. 
·        There is more risk of creating needle points at the edges.

 Performing two processes at the same time risks difficulties.  Inevitably, compromises will need to be made between slumping and tack fusing.  Eventually, it will come to a time when the two process won't work together.

  

A slump taken to tack fusing temperatures is at risk from uprisings at the bottom, needling at the edges, excessive marking on the back, slipping down the mould and thickening

Bubbles in Bottle Slumps

 Any suggestions on how to avoid getting the oblong bubble under the neck of the bottle? This was my first try and I’m really happy with clarity, no devitrification in these.

I used this schedule:

Fahrenheit                    Celsius

300/1150/30                167/620/30

200/1370/20                111/740/20

400/1450/20                222/787/20

AFAP/950/60                AFAP/510/60

150/800/0                    63/427/0

300/100                       167/55/off

The bubble is kind of cool but not sure what it will do when I put it in a bottle mould.

 

To minimise the bubble, you need a bubble squeeze.  There isn't one of sufficient length or at the right temperature in the schedule. The softening point of bottle glass is approximately 720C. Starting the bubble squeeze at ca. 670C/1240F and progressing slowly (ca.50/90F or less) to 720C/1340F may give a better bubble squeeze. 

Also, the anneal soak is a bit low. Bottle glass and float glass both have annealing points of about 550C. You might make use of a lower annealing soak temperature to reduce the cooling time.  It is usually possible to anneal 30C below the published annealing temperature.  In this case that would be 520C.  

There is pretty thick glass in some places due to the way the bottom and neck of the bottle form. You may want to extend your anneal soak to one for 12mm/0.5”.  The soak time for this is 2 hours.  The first cooling segment would be 55C/100F per hour to 475C/888F if you use 520C/970F as the annealing soak.  The second cool segment should be at 99C/180F per hour to 420C/790F.  And the final rate at 330C/600F to room temperature.  It is important to include all three stages of cooling.  The research for my book Low Temperature Kilnforming (Or directly from stephen.richard43@gmail.com) has shown that to get the best stress-free results  use all three stages of cooling.

Bubbles at the shoulder of the bottle are common.  The change in circumference of the bottle at the shoulder means there is a greater amount of glass to “compress”.  Bottles with tapered circumference at the top of the bottle have fewer problems with creating bubbles.  The abrupt change in size at the shoulder causes bubbles to be more common.  A long slow bubble squeeze will allow the shoulder to form more closely in line with the neck. 

There are other things you can do to help avoid the bubbles. One thing is to insert a thin kiln washed wire into the neck of the bottle. This gives a path for the air to escape and allows you to pull it out, although a mark will be left.  You could also think of drilling a hole in what will be the underside at the shoulder to allow air out to the shelf. It does not need to be a big hole.

Bubbles at the shoulder of a slumped bottle are a common problem. It results from the greater amount of glass that has to slump into the space.  This leaves a cavity.  Slower bubble squeezes can help, as well as various venting methods.