Soldering Iron Temperatures

Why use higher temperatures for copper foil using 60/40 than lead came using 50/50 or 40/60? Melting temperatures Part of this is the physical characteristics of the solder The graph shows that all compositions of tin/lead alloy solder (above 20% tin) solidify at the same temperature - 183°C.  Pure lead melts at 327.5°C and pure tin at 232°C.  The various proportions of the two metals melt at different temperatures until at approximately 62% tin, the melting and solidification temperatures are the same.  This is ideal for running a bead in copper foiling, because there is a minimum amount of time for the liquid solder to change shape before it solidifies. Melting temperatures of some solders ·        At 40% tin and 60% lead (40/60) the melting temperature is 238°C.  ·        At 50/50 the melting temperature is 212°C.  ·        At 60/40 the melting temperature is 188°C, just 5°C above the solidification temperature. These figures show the 60/40 solder requires a lower temperature to melt than 50/50 does (24°C difference).  Why should I run the iron at a hotter temperature for 60/40 then? There are two separate elements at work here – the mass of solder being melted and the effects of the pasty range of solder compositions. In soldering lead came you are melting small masses of solder with short pauses between each melting that allow the iron to partially recover. This means running the iron at 370°C is sufficient to maintain a melting temperature above 238°C for 40/60 solder and 212°C for 50/50. In copper foil you are melting much greater amounts of solder, which takes heat out of the iron more quickly than in leaded glass.  The fact is that running a bead requires melting a much greater volume of solder.  The iron needs to run hot to be able to consistently melt the solder without significant periods when the iron is too cool to melt the solder quickly.  This is the reason that irons are run hotter in copper foil. It still does not explain why it is recommended to run the iron hotter for 60/40 than for 50/50 as their melting temperatures are so close. The explanation lies in the pasty range illustrated in the graph shown above.  You can run an iron hotter than needed to melt the solder, because the 60/40 requires fewer degrees to cool and solidify than 50/50.  This allows you to work quickly and still have a good rounded bead. The greater pasty range of 50/50 means that you must be careful about the amount of heat you put into the solder, because the solder will continue to move for a longer time than the 60/40.  The 27°C difference between melting and solidification shows solidification is not instantaneous. This pasty range allows flow while the solder cools. This means that the bead will be less rounded, and it will show minor temperature differences in the wrinkled surface.  If you put even more heat than the 410°C that is normally used for 60/40, it will take even longer for the solder to solidify.  The surfaces effects will then be even more obvious with greater heat.

The short answer

The explanations for running hotter with 60/40 than those solders with more lead centre around the pasty range of solder.  When the pasty range is small, you can put more heat into the solder bead and so work more quickly and still get a good bead.  With wider pasty ranges you need to reduce the temperature of the iron to reduce the heat put into the solder and so keep the pasty range as small as possible.

Darkening leads

There are several ways to darken the leads in leaded panels. Three are to:

use patina on the leads,

brush with on stove blackening with a soft brush, and

simply brush after cementing.

A certain number of people use black patina to darken the leads after cementing and cleaning the panel.  This certainly gives a black result, but it introduces an acid to the panel. I do not do this, nor do I recommend it.

Another method of darkening is to apply stove blackening or black oil paint to the panel to make the leads dark.  I recommend that you put very small amounts on a soft brush and then brush over the leads.  It might have to have a little more colour added for a large panel, but that is better than having to clean up large areas of smudged black over the glass, especially with painted glass.

credit: PicClick UK

But...

You can darken lead came without patina or black colour.  You finish the panel with the scrubbing brush to push whiting against the fillet of lead light cement against the leads as normal.  This has the effect of cleaning the glass as well as stiffening the cement at the edge of the cames. Remove the excess whiting as normal.

But, before picking out all the excess cement once the scrubbing brush process is finished, use a soft brush, such as a shoe brush, over the whole panel.  This can be mechanised by using a soft bristled mop in a drill motor on a slow to medium speed.  This will pick up colour from the cement and spread it evenly over the lead and solder joints. It will give a dark grey appearance to the whole of the leading and solder joints as well as polish up the glass. 

The degree of shine will be dependent on the amount of time you wish to spend, but can be a polished to a very dark grey to black colour.  This will last longer than simple black colour brushed onto the leads, as it is bound by the linseed oil in the cement to the surface of the leads. Also, it quickly dries so that not so much black is transferred to your hands as you handle it.

Making lead cames black during the finishing of a leaded panel is as simple as brushing over the cames before picking out all the excess lead light cement.

Strong Frames for Stained Glass Panels

Metals

Zinc is a popular material for framing copper foiled or leaded glass panels.  It is stronger than lead – up to eight times.  It gives a feeling solidity to the edges of the panel. 

However, it does have some disadvantages.  It is difficult to patina evenly and obtain the same colour as patinaed solder.  It resistance to progressive corrosion is weaker than lead. It requires special tools to fit around curves, making it best for rectangular panels.  It does need a saw to cut evenly, but so do a lot of the stronger metals.  A look at other options is worthwhile.

The strongest option is stainless steel.  This is difficult to cut and has special welding requirements, so is only useful in large and high corrosion installations.

Mild steel is widely available and cheap.  In certain circumstances – mainly small, thin profiles – it can be soldered.  The most secure joining is done with welding.  This requires equipment that stained-glass workers do not usually have.  However, there are a large number of metal workers that can to the work for you.

Brass is more expensive than mild steel.  It is an alloy of copper and tin and so can be soldered with the tools we normally use.  It is about half the strength of stainless steel, but three times the strength of zinc.  The tin content leads to a better patina result than zinc.

Copper is up to twice the strength of zinc, but the price fluctuates more than zinc.  It can be soldered. It requires different patina solutions than used for solder.

Aluminium is the same strength as zinc, but requires different joining methods as aluminium welding is a specialist activity.  Still, it will work on rectangular items with screws at overlapping joints.

More information on the relative strengths of various metals is given in a post on metal strengths.

Strengthening lead came

Lead is weaker than lead but can be bent to conform to curves and indentations for irregular perimeters.  If copper wire is incorporated and attached to the foiled glass, the soldering of the lead came to the joints at the intersections of the solder lines and the coper/came combination will provide greater strength than the zinc alone. 

When wanting to strengthen the perimeter of rectangular or shaped perimeter leaded panels, you can use 10mm “H” lead came soldered as usual to the whole piece as an alternative to soldering the wire to the panel.  Run the copper wire in the open edge of the “H”.  Pull the wire tight at the bottom and sweat solder at each corner.  Run the wire to the top on each side, where you can make a loop for attaching hanging wires and sweat solder the wires there too.  Then close the two leaves of the lead with a fid until they come together forming a single straight line.  If you want, a “U” or “C” edging came can be soldred to the outer edge of the "H" came to cover the line created by folding the leaves.

This post gives more detail about the process of incorporating copper into the perimeter of a leaded panel.

Soldering Lead Came

Soldering lead came is different from soldering electronics or copper foil. For electronic soldering less heat is needed, cleanliness is all important, suitable flux is required, and the iron is held differently, among other things.

Soldering lead came The lead needs to be clean and bright to start with. If it's fairly new lead it should be solder-able without more than a scrubbing of the joints with a brass wire brush. However, if the lead is dull and oxidized, you should scrape the lead in the area to be soldered with a nail, the blade of a lead knife or other sharp edged tool until the bright metal is revealed.

an example of paste flux

Example of a tallow stick.  It has the appearance of a candle, but without the wick.

Example of the application of tallow to a joint

Then the flux can be applied.  Paste flux or tallow works best as neither flows in its cold state.  This means that you can flux the whole panel at one time without the liquid flowing away or drying.  Once the whole panel is fluxed, you do not need to stop during the soldering process.

Example of a gas powered soldering iron. The flat face of the soldering bolt is held in full contact with the joint.

An electric soldering iron is held over-handed (as you would a bread knife) in order to get the handle low enough to have the tip flat on the lead. This will be a 15 to 20 degree elevation from the horizontal. Allow the weight of the soldering iron to do the work for you. 

Let it rest on the joint after you apply the solder between the lead and the iron. In order to heat both pieces of lead you may have to rock the tip slightly to contact all leads being soldered. Take the solder away from the iron so it doesn't become attached to the joint. As soon as the solder spreads, lift the iron straight up. This process will take only a few seconds, much less than 5.

Example of smooth flat solder joints.

Avoid "painting" or dragging the iron across the joint. The object is to have a shiny, smooth, slightly rounded solder joint. Moving the iron and solder around does two things.  It makes for a weak joint as the solder does not have the chance to become stable and so forms a "pasty" joint.  Moving the iron around during the soldering of the joint often provides sharp points where the iron was moved quickly off the join. There should be no points sticking up from the solder joint. If a solder joint is not satisfactory you can re-flux and re-heat. Don't apply too much solder. It's easier to add more solder than to remove excess.

Trimming the Came on Site

There are a variety of reasons for the panel not fitting the opening easily. These can range from poor measurements through parallel, or trapezoidal openings to irregular perimeters of the openings.

In the cases of irregular openings, you can trim the edge cames if you have used 12mm (1/2”) or more wide came. The quickest way of trimming cames to fit the opening is to use a rasp or “surform” tool. The open nature of the teeth, allows the lead to fall away. It is much quicker than using a lead knife, and it puts less pressure on the panel.

Cementing Leaded Panels, part 3

Polishing Lead Cames

Use a soft brush to polish lead came. Don't pick out the cement until the polishing is done, as it provides the colour for darkening and polishing the lead and solder joints. The action with the polishing brush should be gentle and rapid, much like polishing shoes. If the shine does not come, you can use a very little stove blackening (carbon black mixed with a little oil) If you use a lot, you will have a big clean up job. A little stove blackening spreads a very long way.

realglasspainting.com

Before turning the panel a final time, put down paper or cloth, to avoid scratching the solder joints while polishing the other side. The result should be shiny a black came and solder joints that does not come off the way a final buffing with stove blackening does.

Finally, pick out any remaining cement.

Rest horizontally with weather side down for traditional installations. If the panel is going into a double or secondary glazed unit, you may want to reverse this. The reason for having the smallest exposed cement line on the outside is to allow the water to run off the window with the minimum of area to collect. In a sealed unit or for secondary glazing, you may want to have the smallest amount of cement showing inward for appearances, as there is no weathering reason for the traditional method.

Rest for a day. Pick out the cement again. If the cement was stiff enough, there should be no need to do any more picking at the cement after this.

Inserting Glass into the Came

If you have consistent difficulty in sliding the glass into the came, you should consider dressing the came before use. Dressing the came consists of running a fid or other hard material along each of the four flanges of the came. In doing this, you are pressing each flange in turn down against the bench or other smooth surface.

Dressing the cames gives a slight bevel or ramp for the glass to slide over the edge of the came and into the channel of the came. You can dress the whole length at once, or as you cut the pieces off from the main length. Dressing shorter pieces is less likely to bend the came.

Of course there is a second stage of dressing the lead came upon completion of the soldering.

Structural Reinforcement

Leaded light panels often require additional support against wind pressure or vibration. Whether this is needed depends on the size and location, e.g. if in a door or a ventilating window that is constantly being opened and shut.  Large leaded glass windows need some bracing against the force of wind and rain. This can be achieved by using one of the following supports:

• Saddle Bar
• Reinforcing Bar (Rebar)
• Steel Core or Steels
• Zinc Section

Saddle Bars are the strongest method of support and are used in large external windows for preventing panels from bowing inwards. They resist wind pressure in exposed situations. Saddle bars form part of the latteral support structure of the window. These bars are attached to the panel with copper or lead ties.  These ties are soldered to solder joints across the narrow width of the panels.  The bars are fixed to the perimeter of the opening either by the mouldings or by being inserted into holes in the frame. The sides of the opening provide the ancor points for the bar.  The panel is fixed to the bar by twisting the ties around it.

A saddle bar fixed in position at the side and the ties being twisted around the bar.

Sometimes the opening is divided by sideways "T" bars.  Generally the leg of the "T" faces outwards and the panel is set onto the ledge formed by the leg of the "T".  This leg often has a series of holes drilled in the leg, for pins to be inserted to hold the panel in place until the sealant has cured.

An example of "T" bars being used on a small side opening window

Rebar is another external support.  It generally is a zinc coated steel strap about 2mm by 10mm and asl long as needed to cross the panel.  This tends to be soldered directly to the panel at the solder joints either on the inside or outside. One advantage of this material is that it can be bent to conform to the lead lines of the panel.  In consequence it is not as stiff as saddle bars are.

Steel core
Steel cores take two forms - either steel-cored lead or steel strips fitted into the lead cames when leading.  The steel cored lead came is less available nowadays.  They are mainly used in domestic glazing where support is required particularly in leaded lights with diamond panes when they are inserted in continuous diagonal leads. The steel cores are not adaptable to significant curves.

Steel cored lead came cut away to show the steel core

Zinc
Zinc section came is often used to frame a panel that is not glazed into a window or frame. It has been used in the past for both straight and curved lines.  Using it for curves requires a came bending machine to give good, regular curves.  It gives a panel strength for ease of handling, but does not resist sagging or bowing at the centre.  The other disadvantage of zinc is that it corrodes much faster than lead.

Image showing a variety of zinc came

Leading - the First Glass Pieces

After establishing the perimeter lead cames, place the first glass piece into the corner formed by these cames. 

You only need to establish one vertical and one horizontal came to begin with. The other two will be placed at the conclusion of the leading.


Normally, you will be working from the lower left corner toward the upper right corner of the pattern if you are right-handed. The reverse is the case for left-handed people. 

Hold each piece of glass in place with some scrap lead and nail. The scrap lead will prevent the nail from chipping the glass. It's important all glass is held in place with nails so no shifting occurs while working in another area of the panel.

Fitting the rest of the glass to the cartoon is described here. 

Revised Feb 2020

Tucking Lead Came

It is most usual in many countries to butt lead cames against one another. In continental Europe the tucking of cames is more common. In this process, which has the advantages of speed and accuracy, the came is first fitted to the glass and then cut at the edge of the glass.

The first step is to cut the came to the appropriate angle to meet the lead to which it is to be joined. However before presenting the cut came to the joint, one end is lightly tapped with a small hammer to slightly curve the end of the came. This allows it to slip inside the leaves of the came to which it will be soldered.










The came is then shaped to the glass as normal. However, rather than removing the came for the next cut, the came is cut to the length of the glass, often using the glass as a guide. This end is then supported on the lead knife and tapped with the hammer to curve the end, ready for tucking into the next piece of came. Care is required so that you don’t crush the came and break the glass, nor miss the came and hit the glass or your fingers. With practice, there are few accidents.

Diagramatically, the tucked lead looks like this:

Tucking lead provides very accurate joints with no gaps for solder to fall through. Some argue it provides a stronger panel as the hearts of the jointed cames almost meet. The main immediate gain is quicker soldering.

Polishing Panels with Paint and Enamels on the Glass

Do not use black patina on the lead/solder lines on your finished work if there is any painted glass into the panel whether leaded or foiled. This relates to traditional painting on glass, using vitreous paints, fired at ca. 670C and to cold paints often cured in a domestic oven.

When using enamels within the painting, do not let any patina come in contact with the finished production. The patina will etch out all the enamel colour. The patina will etch off the outer layer, either removing the shiny top layer of paint, or the delicate lines of detail work altogether. Copper patina takes a little of the paint off, but not nearly as badly as the black.

Instead, brush the panel with a natural bristle brush, as used for putty clean up, and polish.

Silver stains that have been properly held at the maturing temp, should withstand any patina application, as they have become incorporated at the molecular level with the glass.

Straightening the came

Before using the came it is important to straighten it. This increases the stability of the came during the leading process. Most often nowadays, you use a lead vice. This operates similarly to a cleat on a sailing boat. The more strain that is applied, the tighter the vice grips the came.

You place the end of the came into the vice so that the came appears at the back of the vice. Give the top of the vice a firm tap with your pliers to set the teeth into the came. Grasp the other end of the came with the pliers, and put one foot behind you to brace yourself if the came does slip out of the vice. Draw the came toward yourself until you can see the lead is straight and any kinks have straightened.

Take the came out of the vice and keep it straight. You transport it by grasping each end and keep the came under tension until you get it to the destination. It is often easiest to cut the full length in half before moving it, as it will not then be longer than your arms can stretch.

Remember, this process is to straighten the came to give pleasing lines in the leaded panel. It is not stretching the lead. Stretching the came can weaken the lead.

Dressing the Cames - part 2

Of course, it is not enough just to dress the came at the start. There is an analogous procedure after the whole panel has been leaded, soldered and cemented.

In this instance the term ‘dressing the cames’ means to close or bend the leaves/flanges of the came toward the glass. It provides a neat rounded appearance to the lines, traps the cement you have already added, presents less area for the rainwater to collect, and makes polishing easier. It is also the time when you may break the glass by putting too much pressure on the glass, so be careful!

Dressing the cames is done with an oyster knife or fid. It is best to avoid metal and better to use wood sticks or plastic tools. The pressure is placed on the came rather than the glass. Run the fid lightly at a shallow angle along each flange of the came. It is helpful to use a finger of your other hand to guide the fid along the cames. You may want to do this several times, as repeated light pressure will cause the flanges of the came to move gently toward the glass with less risk of breaking the glass. This can only be done while the cement is pliable. If it is done after polishing, you will need to re-do the polishing, as it will make the edges of the came silvery rather than shiny black.

Snugging the Came to the Glass

It is important to have the came fit snugly to the glass (assuming the glass to be the right size and shape). If it does not, the panel is likely to grow beyond the intended dimensions.

To ensure the came is tucked snugly against the glass, you use a fid of firm material (wood or plastic, for example) to press against the heart of the lead. You can press directly toward the glass, or make multiple passes along the length of the came to ensure the heart is touching the glass all along its length.

You should avoid steel tools, because you may cut the lead, and if the blade is long you will not find it easy to fit along all of the curves.

Dressing the Came

This is a different kind of dressing than what you do in the morning. It relates to how easy it is to slide the glass into the channel of the came.

If you have consistent difficulty in sliding the glass into the came, you should consider dressing the came before use. Dressing the came consists of running a fid or other hard material along each of the four flanges of the came. In doing this, you are pressing each flange in turn down against the bench or other smooth surface.

Dressing the cames gives a slight bevel or ramp for the glass to slide over the edge of the came and into the channel of the came. You can dress the whole length at once, or as you cut the pieces off from the main length. Dressing shorter pieces is less likely to bend the came away from the straight.

Cutting Lead Came

Cutting came is a gentle process rather than an abrupt chopping effort.
There are at least three kinds of implements in common use to cut lead came.

Lead nippers or lead dykes
Lead nippers/dykes are a kind of adapted side cutters, used for cutting wire and by electricians. But these have the bevel only on one side of the jaws, making them almost useless for anything other than cutting lead. This arrangement only crushes the lead on the cut-off side and also leaves a minimum of lead next to the back of the jaws.

In use, the jaws of the dykes are aligned in the same angle as the heart of the lead, cutting across the leaves of the lead. They do not cut from the top and bottom of the came. These are very quick for right angle or very oblique angles on the came. However they are of little use for acute angles.

Lead knives
For more acute angles, blades are more commonly used. These can be either straight edges or curved blades. The straight edge lead knives are essentially putty knives or stiff scrapers sharpened to an acute angle. This kind of knife is normally wiggled from side to side while applying pressure to work through the came.

Other knives are curved to make rocking back and forth easier. There are a variety of knives such as the Pro or Don Carlos. Some look more like a scimitar than a lead knife! These are used to rock along the line where you are cutting the came.

Whatever kind of knife you are using, be sure to be directly above the knife, looking along the blade to ensure vertical cuts.

Saws
Of course, saws are sometimes used. The blade needs to be coarse toothed to enable the soft lead to drop out of the teeth. These saws can be hand held or table saws. Normally, it is quicker to use lead dykes or knives. However, if you are in production mode, a powered table saw may be worthwhile.

Leading Procedure

Cut the leads exactly as the cartoon indicates. In other words, where one line runs into another, that is generally a stopping/starting point for the came.

Always lead to the cartoon line, not the glass. This ensures accurate completion of the panel. If the glass is slightly too small, the cement will take up the gap (assuming the flange of the came covers the glass – if not, you need to cut another piece of glass that fits). If the glass overlaps the cut line, it needs to be reduced.  A description of the process is given here.

This shows the use of a guage to determine where to cut the horizontal lead came.

Cut the ends of the came shorter than the glass. The best way to determine this is to place a piece of came of the dimensions being used for the next edge on the cut line. Use it to determine the length and angle for the cut. The object is to have each piece of came butt squarely against the passing came, to make a strong panel and to make soldering easier.

Leading - Establishing the perimeter

The first thing to be established about the panel is the placing of the came that goes around the edge of the panel.

Fix your cut line cartoon to the work board.  Usually a long strip of masking tape on all the edges will be sufficient.  To establish the placing of the battens, which will form the frame for the leading process, you need to determine the spacing from the cut line.

This shows the initial battens in place and ready for the final two battens to be put in place before soldering.

To determine the size of the off-set of the battens you should cut a short piece of the came you will be using for the outside and use that as a guage.  Place the heart of the came on the outside cut line near one end and move the batten to the side of the came.  Nail that end of the came to the board.  Move the guage came to the other end of the cut line and do the same with the batten as you did for the other end.  Establish one other batten at right angles in the same way.  Then you are ready to place the cames.

Make a straight cut across the came to be used for the outside and put that trimmed end into the corner and along the vertical wood strip. The lead should extend beyond the cut line to accommodate the length of the upper horizontal came. The minimum length must be longer than the width of the perimeter came that will butt against it. If it is even longer, the extra can be trimmed off after the leading is complete or after soldering.


Next butt a trimmed piece of perimeter came along the horizontal wood strip. This one should be shorter than the cartoon. It should be half the width of the perimeter cames to allow the vertical came to butt against it. The reason for having the vertical cames running from bottom to top is that there is a fraction more strength in the heart of the came going all the way to the bottom of the panel, rather than resting on the flanges of the came.

This is how the finished perimeter cames will appear:

These perimeter cames should be held in place with horseshoe nails. Try placing the nails only where a lead line will be soldered in order to cover any nicks the nails might make. Alternatively, you can place the nails at the ends of the perimeter cames to keep them from sliding vertically or horizontally.


If you want to have mitred corners, this post will show you the method.

The next stage of placing the first pieces of glass is shown here.

Leading acute angles

Most of us like flowing lines in leaded glass windows, but these often give very acute angles to be leaded up. One way is to avoid creating intersections by using passing cames.  

But, if the cartoon does not allow for passing cames in acute joints, you have to consider how to cut the came to butt well against the next came. The easiest, but most time-consuming method is as follows:

Determine what the length of the came must be to reach the end of the joint.

Mark your lead there.

Determine what the shortest part of the came will be at the joint and make a faint mark there too.

Cut the came at the first (longest) mark.

Use your lead dykes to cut the heart out of the lead, leaving only the flanges. This is done from the end to just beyond the faint mark you made to indicate the shortest part of the joint.

You then need to smooth the two flanges where the heart was. You can use a fid or your lead knife to draw over the rough interior of the flanges. This enables the flange to be inserted below the came already in place, or to slide the new came over the modified came.

You can trim the upper came flanges immediately to conform to the angle of the joint or do it when the whole panel is leaded. Make a mark with a nail or your lead knife along the edge of the un-modified came. Then raise the flange and use your lead dykes to cut the flange along the line. Fold the flange down to butt against the passing lead and it is ready to solder.