How Many Times Can You Fuse?

Is there a limit to how often a piece can be refused either to add on new pieces or to break up and reuse?

 

Bullseye test their glass to ensure it can go through three firings.  After that you are on your own.  This limitation has been generally accepted within the kilnforming community.

Multiple Firings

Many people report that they fire their glass many times.  I have fired Bullseye glass up to seven times using powders.  The first five firings were to contour fuse.  The final fuse firing was to full fuse.  And then there was a slump firing to make up the seven firings.  These multiple firings assume that the temperature is not taken above full fuse for any of the firings.  The annealing for each of these firings remains as for the calculated thickness of the piece.  No additional annealing time is required for multiple firings without significant changes.

You do not need to consider firing multiple process at once.  The possible number of firings is more than enough to achieve multiple processes.

High Temperature Work

However, the many firings of my piece would not have been possible with high temperatures or long soaks.  The high temperature firings are those that go to casting temperatures (835ºC/1540ºF) and above. These are temperatures for things like pattern bars, melts, and castings.  The glass can change its nature enough to give problems at these temperatures, especially with long soaks.  

If you do multiple firings at high temperatures, I recommend annealing to be from one and a half to two times the expected thickness.  And the rate of cooling will need to be in line with the length of the anneal soak.

Even with care, there can be problems.  I created a thick bowl from transparent glass, of which I was proud.  After an afternoon in the sun while on display months later it showed a crack developing.  I am still convinced - by other similar work surviving – that I annealed it properly. It exhibited minimum stress after the final flat full fuse firing. It was not checked after the slump.

Multiple firings of items with soaks at high temperatures are less likely to survive.  The number of firings possible can be determined only by experience.

Longer Anneal on Each Firing

 Need for an Extension of Anneal Soak on Subsequent Firings

 Sometimes people recommend extending the length of the anneal soak each time the piece is fired. If nothing significant is added, there is no reason to extend the anneal soak.  If the piece can be fired as fast as the previous firing, the annealing will be the same, not longer.

 The physics and chemistry of annealing glass are the same for re-fired glass - without additions - as they were for the first. Extending the annealing soak seems to be more about reassurance of the kilnformer than a necessity.

 Bullseye research has shown that it IS possible to over anneal, locking in stress. If concerned about inadequate annealing, it is best to reduce the cooling rate. Especially over the first 55°C below the anneal soak temperature.  The testing and recording that I have done for a book on tack fusing shows that any differences in the glass - at the end of the anneal soak - will be relieved in that first 55°C/100°F. The remainder of the cool to 370°C/700°F can be about 1.8 times faster, and the final cool ramp can be 3 times faster than the 2nd stage cool. 

 I have observed that a three stage anneal cool is important to successfully anneal a piece. This has been reinforced by the temperature recordings of many firings. Often at the end of the anneal soak there is a little more than the desired 5°C/10°F difference in temperature across the piece. The recordings show this is relieved during the slow firs stage cool and maintained over the next two cool stages. If the kiln is cooling more slowly than the schedule, no electricity is used.  No kiln time is lost.

An example of the first cooling stage

 The first stage cool is key to a successful stress-free result.  If there are concerns about inadequate annealing, two things are important.  Be sure the right length of soak is chosen for the piece being fired.  Second, reduce the speed of cooling by the rates for a piece at least 3mm thicker.  These rates are available from the Bullseye chart for annealing thick slabs.

 The rates are applicable to other than Bullseye glass.  Only the temperatures need to be changed.

 If no significant changes (other than powder, wafer or stringers) are made to the glass before the second firing, no lengthening of the annealing is necessary.

 More detailed information is available in the e-book: Low Temperature Kilnforming.

Achieving Multiple Profiles in One Piece

People ask about whether it is possible to tack fuse additional elements without affecting the profile of the existing piece.

It is as though glass has a memory of the heat it has been subjected to.  For example, a sharp tack will become a slightly rounded tack, even though refired to a sharp tack again.  So, it is impossible to refire a piece to the same temperature or higher without affecting the existing profile.  But it is possible to fire a piece with differing profiles if you plan the sequence of firings.

 

Tack fuse onto existing profile

 

It is possible to add pieces to be tack fused with little distortion to the existing piece through careful scheduling and observation.  There are several requirements.

 •     A moderate rate of advance to the working temperature is required, rather than a fast one. This is because the piece is a single thicker piece with uneven thicknesses.  Also, a slow rise in temperature allows completion of the work to at a lower temperature.  This means there will be less change to the existing profile.

•     A minimal bubble squeeze - or none at all - is required on this second firing.  The added pieces generally will be small, so if possible, eliminate the bubble squeeze.  The requirement is to add as little heat work as possible.

 •     The working temperature should be to a low tack fuse temperature with a long soak. 

 •     Observation is required from the time the working temperature is achieved.  Peeking at 5-minute intervals is needed.  This to be certain that the current tack fuse can be achieved without much affecting the existing profile.  It will be a compromise that you will be able to choose during the firing.  The decision will be whether to retain existing profile and have a sharp tack.  Or a slightly rounded tack and more rounded profile on the original piece.

Planning for multiple levels of tack

It is possible to design a piece with multiple profiles within the completed piece.  You need to plan out the levels and degrees of tack you want before you start firing. 

To do this planning, you need to remember that all heat work is cumulative. In simple terms it means that on a second firing you will start where you left off with the first one. The texture in the first firing will become softer, rounded, or flatter than the second or even the third firing.

Three degrees of tack can be achieved with a little planning.  It works similarly to paint firings.  Some paints fire higher than enamels, and enamels hotter than stain.  You have to plan to fire all the tracing and shading first.  Then you add the opaque enamels, followed by the transparent enamels.  Finally, you add the silver stain.  This is unlike painting on canvas where you build up the image all together.

The same principle is true of a multiple level tack fuse piece.  When creating various profiles in glass, you proceed from firing the areas that will be the flattest first. Then proceed to the areas which will have the least tack last.  This is a consequence of the cumulative effect of heat on re-fired glass.

Plan out the areas that you want to have the least profile.  Assemble the glass for those areas. I suggest that a 6mm base is the initial requirement for anything that is going to be fired multiple times.  Add the initial pieces that will become a contour fuse or a very rounded tack. 

First firing

Put this assembly in the kiln and schedule.  Do not fire to the contour profile temperature.  Instead, you will be scheduling for a sinter or sharp tack. This depends on how many textures you plan to incorporate.  Start with a sharp tack.  Fire at the appropriate rate with a bubble squeeze to about 740°C for 10 minutes and proceed to the anneal cool.   Different kilns will need other temperatures to achieve a sharp tack.

You do not fire to the contour fuse temperature, because the base will be subject to more firings.  Each of these firings will soften the base layers more than the previous one.  This is the application of the principle of cumulative heat work.  When you fire a piece for a second time, there will be little effect until the softening point of the glass is reached. Once there, the glass further softens, giving the effect of a contour fuse.

Any glass that had already achieved contour profile from the first firing will flatten further.  This can be used in cases where the working temperature was not high enough.  Just fire again to the original schedule’s temperature.  Take account of the need for a slower ramp rate to the softening point.

Second firing

Once cool and cleaned, you can add your next profile level of tack fusing to the base.  Note that “level of tack” does not refer to thickness being built up.  It is about the amount of roundness you want to impart to the pieces.  You may be placing this second - sharper – level of tack in the spaces left during the first firing.  Again, schedule to the original approximate 740°C. But remember the base is now a single piece.  You need to slow the ramp rate to the softening point, after which the speed can be increased.  You will not need to retain the bubble squeeze unless you are adding large pieces, or into low areas. 

The second firing will show the pieces added for the second firing to have the profile of the original pieces.  Those pieces having their first firing will have a sharper appearance.

 

credit: vitreus-art.co.uk 

This is a piece where the flower petals and leaves could have been placed for the second firing to give a softer background with less rounded flower details.

 

Third firing

Clean well and add the pieces for the final level of tack.  Schedule the initial rate of advance a little slower than the second firing.  The piece is growing in thickness and complexity.  Once the softening point is reached, the original rate of advance can once again be used up to original temperature. 

Final firing

Clean well and add the pieces for the final level of tack.  Schedule the initial rate of advance a little slower than the second firing.  The piece is growing in thickness and complexity.  Once the softening point is reached, the original rate of advance can once again be used up to original temperature. 

Further notes on multiple firings

It is a good idea to observe the firing, once the working temperature is achieved.  This is to ensure enough roundness is being given to the final pieces being tacked to the whole.  Be prepared to extend the soak if the final pieces are not rounded enough.   Although you should have a good idea of the degree of tack for the final pieces from the previous two firings.

You may need to experiment a little with the temperature and length of soaks at the working temperature.  For example, if the degree of tack is too sharp in the first firing, you can extend the soak or increase the temperature for the next ones. 

If you are firing at 740°C, you may feel you can afford to extend the soak for the subsequent firings, because you are in the lower part of the devitrification range. Consider the risk of devitrification increases with the number of firings of the glass.  The preference is to increase the temperature a bit for subsequent firings to ensure you are not spending a cumulatively long time in the devitrification range but still be able to get the final tack level desired. 

The preference is to increase the temperature a bit for subsequent firings to ensure you are not spending a cumulatively long time in the devitrification range but still be able to get the final tack level desired. 

Because most of your heat work is happening in the low end of the devitrification range, the cleaning regime must be very thorough.  Any chemicals or soaps used must be completely washed off with clean water.  The piece must be polished dry to ensure there are no water marks left on the glass.

You can, of course, have more levels of tack.  One approach would be to start with a sinter, or tack to stick, firing. And repeat that four or more times.  Another is to increase the working temperature and reduce the length of time soaked there.  The shorter time means there is less rounding of each level, allowing the build-up of many levels of tack.  All of these require some experimentation. 

More information is available in the ebook Low Temperature Kilnforming.

Three firings to the same sharp tack profile will give multiple profiles in the finished piece. 

Tack fusing multiple layers

The question:

Full fused 6mm base, with 3mm tacked pieces. It is to be tack fused and slumped now.  Does the number of fuse firings affect the rate of advance, and how long a soak will be required to slump it? 

Multiple firings

If properly annealed each time the glass is fired, the number of firings does not affect how the glass should be fired.  This assumes the same number of layers are being fired.

Tack fusing

Tack fusing this piece will need some care.  The portion to be tack fused is 3 layers thick – overlapping white pieces surmounted by the yellow balls.  The base layer is shaded from the heat by the white, which is generally slower to transmit the heat than many other colours. Bullseye suggests doubling the total height and firing for that thickness. Bob Leatherbarrow suggests 1.5 times the total height for creating the schedule.  Firing Schedules for Kilnformed Glass,  p. 124-6

In this case, because of the amount of white, I would go with the Bullseye suggestion.  My researches for "Low Temperature Kilnforming" also indicated that a tack fuse requires a schedule for two times the thickness. Other levels of tack fusing require different calculations.  The total height of 15mm will be treated as 30mm for scheduling purposes.  This is midway between the thicknesses in the published table.  The rates and times in the table are linear. You can calculate a mid-point in the schedule to get the numbers for your piece.  Half the difference between 25 and 38 is 6.5mm giving 31.5mm.  Using the half-way point will be slightly more conservative than using exact calculations.  It is so close as to make no significant difference.

You will notice that the table gives only annealing times and rates.  There is way you can use this table for the getting initial heating rates.  Look at the final cooling rate for the thickness. If the glass can survive the cooling rate given without showing stress, it will also survive that rate of increase.  The mid-point between 90 and 45 is 67.5°C.  This gives an initial rate of advance (68°C) which can be applied for this piece that has so much shading of the base layer. It should allow the heat to transfer through the white to the base layer without great temperature differences between the covered and the uncovered base layer.

As there is a lot of work in this piece, and it is for someone else, you can be cautious.  Introduce a soak at 260°C of about 30 minutes.  This will help to ensure the heat is distributed to the bottom layer.  If you want to be even more cautious, you can introduce a second 30-minute soak at 371°C before continuing to 540°C.

At 540°C you have passed out of the brittle zone of glass and can increase the rate of advance to 167°C per hour.  The amount of heat work you have put into this piece by the slow rate of advance may enable you to complete the tack fusing with a soak at 720°C.  You will need to observe when the appropriate amount of rounding has been achieved. You will then be able to advance to the annealing portion of the firing. 

For this piece, the annealing soak will be for 5 hours with a cool of 11°C per hour for the first 55°C. Then 20°C per hour for the next 55°C and a final cool of  65°C per hour. This anneal and cool will be about 21 hours, in addition to the ca. 21 hours, in addition to about 10 hours heat up, so don’t expect a quick firing.  Plan two days for the tack fuse.

Slumping

Slumping will need care too.  The piece has uneven layers and the same care is required as for tack fusing.  Experimentation has shown me that scheduling for an additional 3mm (1/8") is needed to ensure the piece is thoroughly heated throughout its thickness.  In addition, the white is stiffer than the other colours and will not bend so easily.  This kind of slow schedule means the glass will be at the same temperature throughout as the slumping starts.

Because of the slow rates of advance, you may be able to slump this piece at 620°C with a significant soak time.  You will need to observe when the piece is fully slumped.  Be prepared to advance to the annealing and cool segments of the schedule.  Some times you need to extend the hold time.  Be prepared for this too. The annealing time and cooling rates will be the same as for the tack fusing.

Further information is available in the ebook Low Temperature Kiln Forming.

Observations on Some Suggestions about Annealing

There are writings from a teacher attempting to make glass fusing simple.  Unfortunately, glass physics and chemistry are very complicated.  Attempting to avoid these complications leads to failures and other difficulties as the practitioner progresses. 

Proper annealing is one of the fundamentals to achieving sound kilnforming results.  Some suggestions have been made by a widely followed person to “simplify” the understanding of the annealing process.  Discussion of the meaning and importance of annealing can be found in many places, including here.  

Annealing temperatures

It has been suggested that the annealing temperatures can be inferred from the CoE of the glass that is being used. Discussion of what CoE is and is not can be found here and here.

Annealing temperatures are not directly related to the expansion coefficient (CoE) of the glass.  This can be shown from the published annealing temperatures for different glasses organised by presumed CoE:

·        “CoE96”: Wisssmach 96 - anneal at 482°C;  Oceanside - anneal at 515°C

·        “COE94”: Artista - anneal at 535°C

·        “CoE 93”: Kokomo - anneal between 507°C and 477°C – average 492°C

·        “CoE 90”: Bullseye - anneal at 482°C; Wissmach90 - anneal at 482°C; Uroboros FX90 - anneal at 525°C

·        “CoE 83”:

o   Pilkington (UK) float - anneal at 540°C;

o   typical USA float - anneal at 548°C;

o   Typical Australian float - anneal between 505°C and 525°C, average 515°C

This shows there is no direct relationship between CoE and annealing temperature.  Do not be tempted to use a CoE number to indicate an annealing temperature.  Go to the manufacturer’s web site to get the correct information.

Temperature equalisation soak

Annealing for any glass can occur over a range of temperatures.  The annealing point is the temperature at which the glass can most quickly be annealed.  However, the glass cannot be annealed if it is not all at the same temperature throughout the substance of the glass.  It has been shown through research done at the Bullseye Glass Company that a temperature difference of more than 5°C will leave stress within the glass piece. To ensure good annealing, adequate time must be given to the temperature equalisation process (annealing). 

From the Bullseye research the following times are required for an adequate anneal soak:

6mm /   1/4"            60 minutes

[9mm /  3/8"           90 minutes]

12mm  / 1/2"          120 minutes

[15mm  /   5/8"       150 minutes]

19mm   / 3/4"         180 minutes

[ ] = interpolated from the Bullseye chart for annealing thick slabs

Anneal Cooling

There are suggestions that a “second anneal” can be used on important pieces.  Other than observing that all pieces are important to the maker, the suggestion should be investigated.  On looking into the idea, it is essentially a second soak at 425°C, which is slightly below the strain point, rather than controlled cool from the anneal soak temperature.

It is reported that the Corning Museum of Glass considers 450°C as the lower strain point – the temperature below which no further relief of strain is possible.  This means that any secondary soak must occur above 450°C rather than the suggested 425°C. Such a soak is unnecessary if the appropriate cooling rates are used. 

Cooling Rate

Except in special circumstances, the cooling rate needs to be controlled as part of the annealing process.  Soaking the glass at the anneal is not the completion of the annealing.  Most practitioners follow the practice of choosing a slow rate of cooling from the annealing soak to some point below the strain point rather than a rapid one with a soak at the strain point temperature.

Annealing is not just the soak time (which is there to equalise the temperature), it is about the rate of the annealing cool too. The rate at which you cool is dependent on the thickness of the glass piece and whether it is all of one thickness or of variable thicknesses.

Even thickness

                                         Cooling rate

Dimension      time (mins)     1^st 55°C   2^nd 55°C

6mm              60                 83°C       150°C

9mm              90                 69°C       125°C

12mm            120                55°C       99°C

15mm            150                37°C       63°C

19mm            180                25°C       27°C

The “first 55°C” and the “second 55°C” refer to the temperature range below the chosen annealing temperature.  So, if you choose to anneal at 515°C, the “first 55°C” is from 515°C to 460°C and the “second 55°C is from 460°C to 405°C.  If you choose 482°C as the annealing temperature, the “first 55°C” is from 482°C to 427°C and the “second 55°C from 427°C to 372°C.

Tack fused/ uneven thickness

If your piece is tack fused, you need to treat the annealing rate and soak as though it were twice the actual total thickness. This gives the following times and rates:

Tack fused

Dimension (mm)                                Cooling rate

Actual     Calculated       time (mins)     1^st 55°C   2^nd 55°C

6            12                 120                55°C       99°C

9            18                 150                37°C       63°C

12          25                 180                25°C       27°C

15          30                 300                37°C       63°C

18          38                 360                7°C         12°C

Contour fusing required firing as though the piece were 1.5 times thicker.  Sharp tack or laminating requires 2.5 times the the actual thickness.

Fusing on the floor of the kiln

There is a further possible complication if you are doing your fusing on the kiln floor, or a shelf resting on the floor of the kiln.  In this case you need to use the times and rates for glass that is at least 3mm thicker than the piece actually is. 

Thus, a flat 6mm piece on a shelf on the floor would use the times and rates for 9mm: anneal soak for 90 minutes, anneal cool at 69°C to 427°C and then at 124°C to 371°C.  It would be safest if you continued to control the cooling to room temperature at no more than 400°C per hour.

But if it were a tack fused piece of a total of 6mm you would use the times and rates for 18mm.  This is using the rates for twice the total thickness plus the additional 3mm for being on the base of the kiln.  This gives the times and rates as being an anneal soak of 360 minutes and cooling rates of 7°C to 427°C and 12°C to 370, followed by 40°C per hour to room temperature.  Any quicker rates should be tested for residual stress before use.

Source for the annealing and cooling of fused glass

These times and rates are based on the table derived from Bullseye research, which is published and available on the Bullseye site.   It is applicable to all fusing glass with adjustments for differing annealing soak temperatures.

Annealing over multiple firings

It has been recommended by this widely followed person that the annealing soak should be extended each time subsequent to the first firing.  I am uncertain about the reasoning behind this suggestion. But the reasons for discounting it are related to adequate annealing and what is done between firings.

If the annealing is adequate for the first firing, it will be adequate for subsequent firings unless you have made significant alterations to the piece.  If you have added another layer to a full fused piece, for example and are using a tack fuse, you will need to anneal for longer, because the style and thickness have been altered.  Not because it is a second firing.  If you are slumping a fired piece, the annealing does not need to be any different than the original firing.

The only time the annealing needs to be altered is when you have significantly changed the thickness of the piece, or the style of fusing (mainly tacking additional items to the full fused piece).  This is when you need to look at the schedules you are planning to use to ensure your heat up is slow enough, that your annealing soak is long enough, and the cool slow enough for the altered conditions.

Determining the annealing point of unknown glass

You don’t have to guess at the annealing temperature for an unknown glass.  You can test for it.  It is known as the slump point test.

This test gives the softening point of the glass and from that the annealing point can be calculated.  This test removes the guess work from choosing a temperature at which to perform the anneal soak. The anneal temperature is important to the result of the firing.  This alone makes this test to give certainty about the annealing temperature worthwhile.

You can anneal soak at the calculated temperature, or at 30°C below it to reduce the anneal cool time.  This is because the annealing can occur over a range of temperatures.  The annealing occurs slowly at the top and bottom of the range. But is at least risk of "fixing in" the stress of an uneven distribution of temperature during the cool when the annealing is done at the lower end of the range.

Do not be fooled into thinking that CoE determines annealing temperatures.  Use published tables, especially the Bullseye table Annealing for Thick Slabs to determine soak times and cooling rates.  Use the standard test for determining the softening and annealing points of unknown glasses.

Further information is available in the ebook Low Temperature Kiln Forming.

You Can Re-fire 3 Times Only - Kiln Forming Myths 25

Bullseye claims that you should only fire a piece 3 times

       

No. They only say the glasses are tested three times and that you are on you own after that.

There is not a general answer that can be given for the number of times you can fire a piece.  In general, Bullseye glass (and probably others, although they do not state what their limits of confidence are) can be fired three times with confidence.  Beyond that you need to do your own testing.

Bullseye states: 

At Bullseye, glasses known to be fairly stable are tested by firing to a top temperature of 1500°F (815°C) and soaking for 15 minutes before annealing. Once cooled, these tests are viewed for stress through polarized light and graded accordingly. We fire glasses known to be less stable three times to make sure they'll perform well under multiple firing conditions, such as those used to fuse and slump a plate.

If you have plans for multiple re-firings, tests are needed. The tests should replicate the temperatures, colours and thickness of the proposed project.  You probably do not need to reproduce the size of the project in these tests though.

Results from each firing should be tested for stress and these tests should include a test for annealing each time. 

You may wish to note that I have fired up to 7 times on several two layer with powder pieces.  Many people fire more times successfully.  It is my belief, but I have no proof, that multiple firings of a piece to slightly lower than full fuse will be more successful than each of them being to the full fuse.  My practice is to go to a rounded tack each of the firings subsequent to the first full fuse, but the final firing will be to a full fuse if I wish a gloss finish.  If I do not, my final firing will be about 10C - 15C below full fuse.