Showing posts with label Scoring speed. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scoring speed. Show all posts

Wednesday 20 March 2024

Testing your Scoring pressure

 Most often people are asked to listen to the sound of scoring.  Unfortunately, different glass styles make different sounds. Float glass makes a particular sound, transparent stained glass makes a slightly different one, and opalescent glass makes almost no sound. Consistent pressure of the right amount is important to the clean breaking of glass. Therefore, we must learn to cut with the same consistent pressure on all types of glass, rather than listening for sound.

It is easy to tell when the scoring is too heavy.  A white line shows along the score.

The heavy score line near the break shows the white line and the irregular break



It is not so easy to tell if the score is too light or just right.


A heavy score in the distance and a lighter score nearer

Pressure

The general recommendations for the pressure to use during scoring is 4.5 – 7 Lbs or 2 – 3 Kg. This is difficult to judge. I found that I needed a means of letting people know for themselves the pressure they were exerting. It is not enough to watch and say that was too hard, that was too soft, etc.

My method of teaching novices how to judge the pressure they are using is to use a digital kitchen scale that can have the scale set to zero. Place a piece of glass no larger than the platform on top of the scales. Zero the scale display.  Have someone watch the scale display while you score in your usual way. Of course, you must not touch the glass with your other hand. Have them tell you the maximum and minimum weights displayed. Keep repeating until you can consistently use that 4.5 – 6.5 pounds (2 - 3Kg) pressure.

The testing setup showing a heavy score on the right and the start of a 1.9kg score on the left.


Consistency

The other important element of scoring is to keep the pressure consistent throughout the score. This test will also show how evenly you apply the pressure during the score. The objective of scoring is to use the correct pressure throughout the length of the score. If your pressure varies significantly during the score, it will be difficult to get the glass to break consistently along the score line. Because the amount of weakness in the surface created by the score is variable.

Your observer can tell you when the pressure is less than optimum or more than desired.  If the pressure variation has a reasonably consistent place in scoring - such as at the beginning, or on a curve - you can fix it. Concentrate on correcting the fall off in pressure. For example, most people start off with a lighter pressure than further into the score.  Getting the feel of the correct pressure will enable you to apply it right from the start of the score. Sometimes, people increase the scoring pressure when they come to curves. This test will show if that is true for you.

This curve was scored with 4.3kg pressure showing that heavy pressure can result in break outs from the score line

This testing can take quite a while. But it is worth the time spent in getting the scoring pressure right to reduce the number of unwanted breaks. However, it is not a one-time test. When I begin to have difficulties in breaking glass, I go back to this test to check whether I am scoring too heavily. In my scoring practice, I find that my best ones are those with 1.8 to 2.5kg (4.0 to 5.5 pounds) with the cutter I use.  This is less than many, but it has worked well for me for years.

There are, of course, other elements that go to making a good score and break. But the most important thing in scoring and breaking opalescent glass is to avoid too heavy a score by listening for a sound. Cut to a consistent pressure whatever sound is heard.

 

 

 

Wednesday 6 September 2023

Testing your Scoring Pressure


Most often people are asked to listen to the sound of their scoring.  Unfortunately, different glass styles make different sounds. Float glass makes a particular sound, transparent stained glass makes a slightly different one, and opalescent glass makes almost no sound. Consistent pressure of the right amount is important to clean, consistent breaking of glass. Therefore, we must learn to cut with the same consistent pressure on all types of glass, rather than listening for sound.

Pressure

The general recommendations for the pressure to use during scoring is 6 - 7 Lbs or 2.7 – 3.2 Kg. This is difficult to judge. I found that I needed a means of letting people know for themselves the pressure they were exerting. It is not enough to watch and say that was too hard, that was too soft, etc.

A digital kitchen scale approximately 15cm/6" square


This is my method of teaching novices how to judge the pressure they are using. I get out a digital kitchen scale that can have the scale set to zero whatever is on top of it. Place a piece of glass no larger than the platform on top of the scales. Zero the scale display.  Have someone watch the scale display while you score in your usual way. Of course, you must not touch the glass with your other hand. Have them tell you the maximum and minimum weights displayed. Keep repeating until you can consistently use that 6 - 7 pounds (2.7 - 3.2Kg) pressure.



Scoring at 2.288kg/5 lbs



Score lines for 1.8kg and 3.5kg/4 lbs and 8 lbs. you can barely see the lighter score line.
But both break well as straight lines

Straight lines scored with light, medium and heavy pressures break well.




When curves are scored heavily breakouts occur. This was scored at 4.3kg/9.5 lbs 

Consistency

The other important element of scoring is to keep the pressure consistent throughout the score. This test will also show how evenly you apply the pressure during the score. The objective of scoring is to use the correct pressure throughout the length of the score. If your pressure varies significantly during the score, it will be difficult to get the glass to break consistently along the score line. This is because the amount of weakness in the surface created by the score is variable.

Your observer can tell you when the pressure is less than optimum or more than desired.  If this has a reasonably consistent place in scoring, you can concentrate on correcting that. For example, most people start off with a lighter pressure than further into the score.  Getting the feel of the correct pressure will enable you to apply it right from the start of the score. Sometimes, people increase the scoring pressure when they come to curves. This test will show if that is true for you.

This testing can take quite a while. But it is worth the time spent in getting the scoring pressure right and reduce the number of unwanted breaks. However, it is not a one-time test. When I begin to have difficulties in breaking glass, I go back to this test to check whether I am scoring too heavily. In my scoring practice, I find that my best ones are those with 1.8 to 2.5kg (4.0 to 5.5 pounds) with the cutter I use.  This is less than many, but it has worked well for me for years.


There are, of course, other elements that go to make up a good score and break. But the most important thing in scoring and breaking opalescent glass is to avoid too heavy a score by listening for a sound. Cut to a consistent pressure whatever sound is heard.

Wednesday 22 August 2018

Diagnosis of Cutting


If your scoring and breaking of your glass is not going well, you need to diagnose the reasons.  There are always a lot of suggestions that warming the glass will solve the problem. Yes, warming glass may help. A discussion of the effect is here. But it will not overcome any faults in the basic skills of scoring.


A lot of images, shown on the internet, of straight line scores failing to break along the score, indicate some possible elements in scoring that lead to these unwanted break-outs. 

One possibility is you are using too much pressure. A discussion of the amount of pressure required is here.  You should be scoring to the pressure required, rather than any sound that may come from scoring.  This is emphasised when cutting opalescent glass.  The correct scoring pressure makes almost no sound or only a gentle rumble as it cutter moves over the undulations of the glass.  The most frequent reason for more difficulty in breaking opalescent glass is excessive pressure while attempting to get the same sound as from transparent glass.  There are even a few transparent glasses that make little or no sound when being scored with the correct pressure.


Another common problem in scoring is keeping an even pressure throughout the score.  It can be difficult to keep the pressure even on complicated cuts.  When the cartoon has multiple curves or deep concave lines, it can be difficult to keep the pressure even as you move your body around to follow the line.  One piece of advice I received early on in my learning was to rehearse the score allowing the cutter wheel to move along the score line with virtually no pressure.  This shows how the piece of glass needs to be oriented to ease your movement around the glass to make the score.

Slowing the cutting speed can help to keep the pressure evenly distributed along the score.  Straight lines are often scored quickly.  But, even on straight lines, slowing the speed can make the pressure more even throughout the score.  It can also avoid variable speed during the scoring, which leads to different forces being placed on the glass.  The pressure may be consistent, but the effective pressure is greater when slow than when fast scoring is used.  If the speed is variable, the effective pressure differs along the score line.


A fourth thing that may be happening on straight lines is that the cutter wheel is at an oblique angle to the direction of the score.  This will often be heard as a scratching sound as you move along the score line.  This can be overcome by a gentle pressure against the straight edge you are using to align your score.  Of course, the straight edge needs to be held firmly to avoid having it move.  Allowing the head of the cutter to have a little freedom of movement also helps keep it parallel to the straight edge.


All this is merely speculation about your scoring practice.

You need to get someone to observe you scoring.  They do not need to be experts, nor other glass artists.  They just need to be observant. Tell them what you are looking for in each of the four elements of scoring and have them observe only one thing at a time.

First get scales that you can zero when you have a small piece of glass on it. Score without touching the glass. Have the observer tell you if the pressure was consistent throughout the score, and if you are in USA, whether the pressure was above 7 pounds or below 4 pounds. (For the rest of the world 3kg to 1.8kg). Practice until you can score consistently at about 2.2kg (ca. 5 pounds).

Second, have the observer stand a little distance from you. Score toward the observer. They need to observe whether your cutter is perpendicular to the glass while scoring and if there is any variation.


Next, they need to tell you if your head was directly above the cutter all the way through the score. They will be able to see whether your eye is directly above the cutter

Is your body behind the cutter, or do you use your arm to direct the cutter?  The observer will be able to tell that when you are scoring curves. The most consistent speed and pressure is delivered when the cutter is steered from your torso, rather than your arm and wrist.  It slows the scoring action, gives smoother curves, and more even pressure.


The last element, you can do yourself.  Once you are doing all the things above, you will be able to hear any scratching noise, rather than the gentle creaking noise of an even score with adequate pressure.  If the scratching noise is intermittent or only at one point, the likelihood is that you are twisting the cutter head, so the wheel is not in line with the score line.